Selena Gomez’s “Pink Whip” Nails Are Fit for Glinda, the Good Witch—See the Photos

Look! It’s Glinda! Oh wait… it’s actually Selena Gomez, wearing the most Good Witch-worthy manicure we’ve seen all season.

The newly engaged Gomez showed off her gorgeous marquise-cut diamond ring on Instagram Stories and after “ooh”ing and “ahh”ing over the gemstone, we shifted focus to the manicure, and does it not look like something Glinda would absolutely love? Firstly, it’s definitely pink, the Good Witch’s signature color, though it’s a soft, pearly wash of the shade versus a full-on bubblegum or baby pink.

Manicurist Tom Bachik shaped Gomez’s nails into soft, mid-length almonds and reached for his Click Colors Magnetic Gel polish in Pink Whip, a frosty, ultra-pale pink to craft the subtle shade. It’s not quite sheer, but you can still see a tiny bit of Gomez’s natural nails underneath, and the microshimmer catches the light beautifully. You know who else would love this color? The Sugarplum Fairy! It’s the color of sparkly, magical ballgowns and tutus, giving it a festive feel even though it’s not in the typical holiday color palette of red, green, gold, or silver.

Though we can’t tell for sure, given the Instagram Story selfie snapshot, it looks like Gomez is wearing a similar shade on her eyes, and her lipstick is definitely pink—probably a Rare Beauty shade.